X-Men: Grand Design

X-Men: Grand Design

Over six tumultuous decades, the X-Men have carved a singular place in comic book lore and popular culture. From their riotous birth in the '60s, to their legendary reboot in the '70s, to their attitude adjustment in the '90s, to their battle against extinction in the '00s, the X-Men have remained unquestionably relevant to generations of readers, the ultimate underdogs in Over six tumultuous decades, the X-Men have carved a singular place in comic book lore and popular culture. From their ri...

DownloadRead Online
Title:X-Men: Grand Design
Author:Ed Piskor
Rating:
Genres:Sequential Art
ISBN:1302904892
Format Type:Paperback
Number of Pages:120 pages pages

X-Men: Grand Design Reviews

  • Dave
    Apr 15, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

  • Daniel
    Oct 05, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

  • Andrew
    Jan 02, 2019

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

  • Aaron
    Apr 25, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

    Great summary of the first 100 x-men books. Ed Piskor is great. ...

    3.5/5 ...

    Meh. It was ok. Maybe if I was a bigger X-Men fan I?d enjoy it more. It read like a summary or history of the X-Men. Very little dialogue. ...

    Wanna get caught up on a couple decades of X-Men history without battling your way through those old issues? I'm a huge comics fan, and I'm willing to admit that reading most titles from start to present day can be a real slog. Comics were...rough back in the 60's. Luckily, Ed Pisko...

    The X-Men & I go way back. Like to the original run, almost all the way back. And I loved this. Piskor synthesizes decades of X-Men stories to tell a chronologically linear narrative. It's not the way that the story was originally told, but it works. Classic X-men stories told w...

    This was a pretty interesting read that I think any fan of the X-Men would like to dive into. At its core, the book actually summarizes the most important plotlines found in the comic over the course of their first 30 years of existance (1960s-1980s). It is not a lengthy book, but it d...

  • Peter Derk
    Dec 26, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

  • Tiago
    Mar 03, 2019

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

  • Matt
    Apr 14, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

  • Burgoo
    Apr 30, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

    Great summary of the first 100 x-men books. Ed Piskor is great. ...

    3.5/5 ...

    Meh. It was ok. Maybe if I was a bigger X-Men fan I?d enjoy it more. It read like a summary or history of the X-Men. Very little dialogue. ...

    Wanna get caught up on a couple decades of X-Men history without battling your way through those old issues? I'm a huge comics fan, and I'm willing to admit that reading most titles from start to present day can be a real slog. Comics were...rough back in the 60's. Luckily, Ed Pisko...

    The X-Men & I go way back. Like to the original run, almost all the way back. And I loved this. Piskor synthesizes decades of X-Men stories to tell a chronologically linear narrative. It's not the way that the story was originally told, but it works. Classic X-men stories told w...

  • Dylan
    Jul 20, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

  • Will Robinson Jr.
    Nov 30, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

  • andrew y
    May 26, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

  • Jack Phoenix
    May 24, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

  • Przemek SkoczyƄski
    May 11, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

  • Q.
    May 19, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

    Great summary of the first 100 x-men books. Ed Piskor is great. ...

    3.5/5 ...

  • Brendan
    Nov 12, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

  • Brandon Forsyth
    Aug 05, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

  • Shaun Connor
    Jan 04, 2019

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

    Great summary of the first 100 x-men books. Ed Piskor is great. ...

  • Chad
    Aug 03, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

  • Scott S.
    Feb 27, 2019

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

  • High Plains Library District
    Jan 02, 2019

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

    Great summary of the first 100 x-men books. Ed Piskor is great. ...

    3.5/5 ...

    Meh. It was ok. Maybe if I was a bigger X-Men fan I?d enjoy it more. It read like a summary or history of the X-Men. Very little dialogue. ...

    Wanna get caught up on a couple decades of X-Men history without battling your way through those old issues? I'm a huge comics fan, and I'm willing to admit that reading most titles from start to present day can be a real slog. Comics were...rough back in the 60's. Luckily, Ed Pisko...

  • Logan
    Jan 26, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

  • Quentin Wallace
    May 18, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

  • Nicholas Palmieri
    Mar 28, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

  • Blindzider
    Apr 08, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

  • John H
    May 10, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

  • Adam Stone
    Apr 03, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

  • Adam Spanos
    Apr 24, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

  • Brian Dickerson
    Apr 15, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

  • Jamie Connolly
    Feb 21, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...

    If you're looking for a primer on early X-Men history, this is the way to go. Piskor sort of remakes old X-Men stories with new art, and he mixes in some of the better-known and more obscure stuff. It makes for a great blend. Plus, the format has yellowed, old comic book pages, it's ov...

    Komiks napisany z mi?o?ci do X-Menów. Traktowa?em to jak skrypt, który z grubsza zarysuje ca?o?? i w zasadzie troch? tak jest, ale to niesie ze sob? dosy? dramatyczne konsekwencje, np. tak?, ?e ca?o?? jest bardzo, ale to bardzo skrótowa, w?tki bywaj? sp?ycone maksym...

    The first half of this was great, because Piskor got to weave together all of the disparate elements of X-Men history from before the actual series started, previously only referenced here and there via flashback. The second half was a much more straightforward retelling of the events ...

    I love the design, art style, and narrative that Piskor uses in retelling the early days of the X-Men. This book easily sits beside his volumes of Hip Hop Family Tree both physically and via content. One can dream that Piskor tackles other Marvel titles / groups. Punisher: Grand...

    This book oozes with nostalgia. I have a fond history with the X-men. Growing up in the 90s I was big fan of the Fox X-men animated series. Saturday mornings were the best at that time and X-men was one of my go to shows along with Batman the Animated Series, Spider-man, Dragon Ball Z ...

    The X-Men were the characters that got me into comics. I picked up all four issues of the X-Men Vs. Fantastic Four in the first comic book store I ever went to, and immediately fell in love with comics, and then read X-Men: Days of Future Present and was so confused that I stopped read...

    The Marvel Universe is messy, as is to be expected of something written by hundreds of authors over 50+ years with hundreds of different characters. And the irony of a book titled "Grand Design" about characters in the MU is that there clearly is no such thing. Marvel comics are just a...

    I wanted to like this more than I did. Doing a "Hip Hop Family Tree" take on the X-Men sounds like a great idea, but it turns out this approach works better with real life history than with fictional soap operas. The first issue, in which Piskor organizes and recontextualizes decad...

    As I was putting this away, I had to move Darwyn Cooke's THE NEW FRONTIER, his retelling of the early years of the DC heroes, and it struck me how similar these two projects are. Both are from beloved independent comics creators, tackling an established mythology for which they clearly...

    A truly ambitious undertaking, weaving the entire disjointed history of the X-Men into a cohesive tale. I applaud the project. Unfortunately it fell flat for me. It's a high-speed sightseeing tour through the major events of the team's life, checking off all the boxes as it careens thr...

    I loved this. Yeah, there were some abrupt transitions in the story, but when you consider the hundreds of X-Men comics, some of which probably don't mesh together very well, this book is an amazing achievement. This is basically an attempt to create a coherent narrative from the hundr...

    The best and most ambitious X-Men project in decades! That Piskor is able to not only organize all of the tangled X-Men continuity but also make a coherent and interesting story out of it is a bit of a minor miracle. Buy it now. You won't be sorry. ...

    Whether you're an initiated X-fan or a new-comer to Marvel's mighty Mutants or simply a fan of fabulous, quirky comics with an indie feel, X-Men: Grand Design cannot be missed. ...

    Now that's how you write a comic. I loved the framing as a Watcher finally "recording" these tales. I loved the art after a minute of acclimation. I loved the disparate, manifold stories woven into a cohesive whole. A "Grand Design", even. ...sorry ...

    Great summary of the first 100 x-men books. Ed Piskor is great. ...

    3.5/5 ...

    Meh. It was ok. Maybe if I was a bigger X-Men fan I?d enjoy it more. It read like a summary or history of the X-Men. Very little dialogue. ...

  • A. Hydra
    May 14, 2018

    The appearance of this volume was often distinguished-looking and unique. The artwork style was meant to invoke 60's / 70's-era Marvel (right down to the yellowed pages), and the 'treasury edition' format - I have a Captain America issue from the bicentennial year somewhere in my colle...

    Ed Piskor brings the Hip Hop Family Tree treatment to the X-Men. Set in an old school, over-sized treasury format, Piskor brings in all of the flashbacks from the X-Men books throughout the years and gives us the historical highlights of those that would eventually form the X-Men. Issu...

    I really don't know where to begin with this book. Perhaps I should describe the yellowed pulp paper, or the thick line work, or the Kirbyesque faces and costumes. Maybe I should be praising the way Mr. Piskor has so beautifully highlighted the strangeness of the Silver Age X-Men...

    This was a mixed bag. One one hand, the art is good and it's printed on a different type of paper that makes it feel like an authentic older comic. But the thing is, there's really not a fluid story here and it's more just a collection of events that happened in the X-Men comics during...

    I like the idea of this and being a fan of the X-Men this project appealed to me. After reading it though, I'm underwhelmed. In this volume, Piskor takes all of the stories starting with the Lee series to just before Claremont's run, condenses them and puts them in a chronological o...

    4.5 Something different and unlike most of the graphic novels lingering around. Ed Piskor has created something that is a labour of love for the X-Men universe and it's nice to find something a little more retro. The book might seem light but it was quite a heavy one sitting read an...

    A brilliant homage to the early years of the X-Men, recommended to new fans who never had the chance to read the mutants first run, and to old fans who want to relive these classic moments. ...

    Collects X-Men: Grand Design issues #1-2 and X-Men (1963) issue #1 (recolored by Ed Piskor) This is an awesome book chronicling the early days of X-Men history. As far as I could tell, from my limited X-Men knowledge, the stories detailed in this collection are set during the 1960's...

    I thought this was a very funny and clever way to catch up on a massive and chaotic X-men history and Piskor does so with love, humor, and detail. I am looking forward to the next batch of stories this year. ...

    Simple plot but not bad, final expected but not bad, is an easy book to read and good for people who do not have a specific time for this activity since you can read in the truck, free spaces, etc. ...